Skip to the content
  • +1.616.329.0753
  • innercitadelconsulting@protonmail.com
Inner Citadel Consulting
  • Home
  • The ICC Advantage
    • About Peter
    • Testimonials
    • Philosophy
  • What’s EI?
  • EI at Work
    • EI and Teams
    • Workshops & Team EI Projects
  • Executive Coaching
  • Blog

Four Ways to #bebetterdobetter

Uncategorized
    • By Peter Anderson
    • No Comments on Four Ways to #bebetterdobetter
    • October 2, 2020

Four Ways to #bebetterdobetter

“What awareness brings is a new sense of responsibility and agency, not an actual new responsibility or agency.”

One of the double-edged swords of self-isolation is a lot of time to be introspective. This isn’t because I’m less busy or anything like that. It’s that certain kinds of distractions (like dinners with friends, or travel to see family) are gone and the other distractions (like binge-watching Netflix) just have their limits. So, that has meant that I feel like I’ve been worrying or meditating more than I might have before. What the hell is happening to us, to America? How can we be better? How can we do better? I believe that our common human nature can pull us to be better and do better, but worry that that same nature, perverted, is destroying us.

This week, two ten year old boys in a fairly peaceful rural township near where I grew up in Canada attacked another young boy because of the color of his skin, ran him over with a motorized scooter and stomped on his arm breaking it in two places. It was “newsworthy” — hateful, inhumane things like that happen all the time, after all — because the boys were ten. I’ve got to believe that such specific cruelty is generated out of circumstances, the contexts of our lives, not out of our true human nature.

Can we respond?

When we are socialized and conditioned in certain ways, can we break free? I believe that our common human nature tends to the better. While coaching or teaching, I often find (this goes for myself too) that Stoic ideas are very attractive to people, make sense, drive positive growth, because the Stoics assume the best is possible. But there is almost always a point when a person says, “Whoa! What?” as the consequence of a certain Stoic idea plays out fully. Embracing our human nature is like that.

Could a full response to our common human nature make greater demands on us than our social conditioning and personal boundaries have prepared us for or dispose us to accept? Almost certainly, but that doesn’t mean it’s not possible or even desirable, just hard. If we see a better path that is harder to walk, will we take it? Seneca once asked a friend, “Can you reach a peak by walking on flat ground?” If you want to be better and do better, it turns out you need to do that work yourself.

Four-Personae Theory

The Four-Personae Theory, preserved in Cicero from one of his teachers, Panaetius, offers a way to understand the complexity of who, what, and where we are without giving even an inch on our moral responsibility to do better in every moment. For the Stoic Panaetius, human beings are social animals, automatically placed within family and social contexts, and we live our lives influenced by external circumstances of all kinds. But these circumstances (family, geography, environment, class, etc.), while they are inevitable and shape our behaviors and perspectives, do not eliminate our agency. And because they do not eliminate our agency, we must meet the moral and spiritual challenge of responding fully to our human nature.

For the Stoics, that human nature was to live according to reason (intellectual and emotional), to evaluate our perceptions, emotions, and beliefs in order to do the appropriate thing in every circumstance. What do you believe our common human nature demands from us? The four Personae (four roles, or identities) present a system that can account for our circumstances and current behaviors while giving us the agency to change. The first identity is the individual as a human being. A human being is rational, self-directing, self-aware, with an inborn sense of virtue.

The second identity is the individual as an agent. We all can make choices, even if they are interior, mental ones, about how to act. In fact, many, many things we do every day — while they feel automatic or habitual — began at some point as a choice. Which shoe did you put on first today, left or right? Of course, most of these things are automatized because we would find it very hard to function given the number of “decisions” we have to make — the brain is amazing — but that doesn’t mean we can’t make a choice. And yes, which shoe I put on first hardly carries huge moral weight. Other automatized decisions do. Becoming aware that we can make a choice, that we are agents in our own lives, is a huge step toward positive change.

The third identity involves our past and current circumstances. Where and to whom were we born? What have we experienced, felt, endured, embraced? All of these things have shaped us as individuals. Some have come to us by our own choices; many have just happened to us. But all of them have significance for who we are in this moment and how we will make choices.

The fourth identity is in essence the kind of person we want to be, a choice of life. What do you want for yourself? How does what you want for yourself impact how you deal with the world or treat other people? And here is the crux of the problem. How can I become aware of different possibilities if my circumstances limit them? What happens when we choose to follow ways of life that are hateful, bigoted, self-centred … Aren’t we back at the beginning again?!

“Up to you.”

As usual, Stoicism leads us to a set of conclusions about life or humanity, and then says, “up to you”. Anyone who has spent time with Stoicism as a holistic philosophical system understands why that must be the case. But it’s pretty damn annoying for everyone else. Here’s the thing though — while you are who you are because of a range of things — genetics, society, religion, etc. — you are STILL making your choices about many, many more things than you think you are. The system with which we navigate the world (our brain and body) makes it easy to assume many things that we do are not choices, like what shoe we put on first or how we perceive a group of young people having fun together.

The moral stringency of the Stoics demands that we take a good, long look at those automatic behaviors and those perceptions. And this is not just a moral imperative. The decisions we make and actions we take today are the circumstances and contexts of our choices tomorrow. It really, really matters, for every action you will take in the future, to consider your actions and decisions today. What people see and experience determines in a lot of cases what they think is possible. Chew on this for a minute: are you limiting or expanding possibilities for people around you with your behaviors?

Our responsibility

This feels like a LOT of pressure. The truth is, this has been true your whole life. What awareness brings is a new sense of responsibility and agency, not an actual new responsibility or agency. So, in between binge-watching, zoom social hours, walking in the woods … whatever, we can all find time for some of the important questions. What are the key or essential beliefs that affect our decision-making processes? Where did they come from? To what extent and in what ways is “choice” implicated in our decision-making? Do I understand the full range of choices open to me at any given time? What is the inter-relationship between “What I am”, “What I can do”, “What effect my circumstances have” and “What my purpose is in acting”? What are your four personae? Am I going to worry today or meditate?

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Contact us today

  • Email
    innercitadelconsulting@protonmail.com
  • Phone
    616.329.0753
  • Address
    www.innercitadelconsulting.com

Recent Posts

  • Combating Toxic Leadership
  • Four Ways to #bebetterdobetter
  • Monday, again?… No. Notice-Engage-Empower, again.

Categories

Archives

  • October 2020
  • September 2020
  • May 2020
  • April 2020
  • March 2020
  • February 2020

Contact

  • Email
    innercitadelconsulting@protonmail.com
  • Phone
    616.329.0753
  • Address
    Potsdam, New York

Like us on Instagram

inner_citadel_consulting

What do you think about when you hear the word #mi What do you think about when you hear the word #mindfulness?

Mindfulness and #meditation are not the same thing. It's true - meditation can be mindful and mindfulness can be practiced in meditation. But they are simply not the same thing. I work with clients who have had such bad experiences with #mindfulnesspractice that used #meditating, shamed or ashamed because they found sitting painful or because they couldn't still their minds, or because closing their eyes in that context activated a stress response. Partly this is bad teaching, but also it is a confusion of practice. The "failure" is not theirs, but the result is that they resist #emotionalintelligence development and other kinds of #mindfulnessatwork training. 

Meditation is a specific kind of mindfulness. Mindfulness is being powerfully #aware of your self in the present moment, deliberatively non-judgmental, balancing #equanimity and #purpose in decisions and actions.

#wellnessatwork #mindfulleadership #sitting #anywhere #everywhere #letsgetreal #wednesdaywisdom #genostribe
I love this quote from Epictetus about the "good f I love this quote from Epictetus about the "good flow of life"...

But it's not really that he's saying "go with the flow", he's talking about #contentment and #peaceofmind achieved through understanding what is #uptoyou. In #stoicphilosophy that phrase (up to you, epi soi) is not a release from social responsibility and definitely not a release from choosing right action. It is a call to action, a reminder that our human nature requires us to engage in the thing that makes us uniquely human - the capacity to choose our response, what is up to us, in the "flow" of life around us. A tighter translation of "good flow of life" might be "YOU will flow well". #stoicism is not, as it often is portrayed, an inhuman control of emotions - it is a full engagement with being human, a rational, spiritual animal.

My #genostribe friends will recognize #emotionalintelligence, #emotionalreasoning, #selfmanagement. Others will see connections to the ideas that inspire them. Me? I'm hoping for a good "flowday" ... #TGIF!

#fridayfeels #fridaythoughts #innercitadelconsulting #happiness
Why does #emotionalintelligence show up consistent Why does #emotionalintelligence show up consistently as "most needed" on all of the #futureofwork lists? Well, it'd be pretty easy to argue it's *always* been needed but we could also correlate the growing awareness of the need for #ei against the increasing use of #ai ...

I love this idea of the many YOUs you are. #Understanding, #perspective, #selfawareness ... when we have a better handle not only on how we show up at work, but how we transition between work and other relationships, we can begin to be more #resilient and be better #leaders. If you haven't had a workplace behavior assessment recently, I cannot recommend strongly enough that you get one. 

If you want to talk about the Genos International assessments, I'd be happy to connect. But (while I have strong opinions about what works and is #valid and #reliable), the key is to simply get a start. Your YOUs are worth it! And if you're leading teams as we all prepare to pivot back into workspaces... let's talk.

#personaldevelopment #leadership #growthmindset #wednesdaywisdom #genostribe
Why is it that the simplest things are sometimes s Why is it that the simplest things are sometimes so hard? I love this quote by the French Alphonse Karr (see below for the original quote) ... who among other things was a floriculturist.

Awareness in #emotionalintelligence training is not about hyper-focus, it's about a holistic perception and the choice to focus on a particular thing from a specific viewpoint, all within context. That's partly why I use Genos International assessments, which are context-rich. 

This ability to be contextually aware and to focus from a specific perspective is simple and sometimes hard to do. Like all skills, it gets better with #practice - #coachingworks too. Are you focusing so much on thorns you can't see the rose anymore?

“De leur meilleur côté tâchons de voir les choses:
Vous vous plaignez de voir les rosiers épineux;
Moi je me réjouis et rends grâces aux dieux
Que les épines aient des roses.” 
from Voyage autour de mon jardin (1845).

#tuesdaythoughts #growthmindset #awarenessmatters #shiftyourmindset #genostribe #perspectiveshift #embracethejourney #roses
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Your Inner Citadel

Inner Citadel Consulting provides people culture and leadership solutions to organizations and individuals in the Non-Profit and Higher Education sectors.

We will help you unravel the complexity of the issues that brought you to us and provide focused, actionable plans to help you build your own Inner Citadel.

Proudly powered by WordPress | Theme: Consultera by Wpazure.
Back To Top